EF
Eduardo Ferraz
7mo ago
#7

Feature Request: External Storage & iCloud Offloading Support

Hello,

I hope you're doing well.

First, I want to say that I absolutely love your app, BookShelves eBook Reader. It's one of the best solutions I've found for managing and reading ebooks in multiple formats, especially with its clean interface and iCloud integration.

However, I've run into a significant limitation in my current setup, and I wanted to share it in case there might be a workaround or a future improvement.

I have a large personal library of ebooks (around 400GB) stored on an external hard drive. My Mac, however, only has a 256GB internal SSD with limited available space. Because the app relies on iCloud for syncing and storage, I'm unable to import and manage my full library without running into storage constraints.

What I'm hoping for is one of the following possibilities:

  • Support for importing and reading books directly from external storage without copying them into iCloud/local storage
  • An option to "offload" or keep files externally while maintaining their organization within the app
  • More flexible iCloud usage (e.g., metadata synced via iCloud, but files stored externally)
  • Any alternative workflow that would allow large libraries to be managed without requiring full local or iCloud storage

I believe this kind of feature would be incredibly valuable for users with large collections like mine.

Thank you for your time and for creating such a great app. I'd really appreciate any guidance or insight you might have.

Review 1

7 people liked this

1 comment

Hi,

Thank you for the detailed request, and thanks to everyone who voted for it.

Today BookShelves keeps book files in its own storage on the device, or in iCloud when iCloud sync is on. With iCloud sync, and Optimize Mac Storage turned on in macOS, books you have not opened for a while can be removed from the Mac and download again when you open them, but the whole library counts against your iCloud storage.

We are now looking at where else book files could be kept, and are considering three options:

  • An external drive connected to the Mac. Books on it could only be opened on that Mac while the drive is connected, and would not sync to other devices.
  • Your own cloud storage, such as Google Drive, OneDrive or Dropbox.
  • S3-compatible storage, such as a bucket at Backblaze B2, Wasabi or Cloudflare R2, or MinIO on your own NAS.

With the two cloud options, a book would be downloaded when you open it, so the library would take little space on your devices.

If you want this, a short comment here would help us decide:

  1. Which of the three would suit you best, and why?
  2. Do you use BookShelves only on the Mac, or also on an iPhone or iPad?
  3. About how large is your library, in number of books and in gigabytes?

Best regards

BookShelves · 27d ago

Sign in

Sign in to post, comment, and vote.

Sign in with Apple Sign in with Google